How to Choose a Student Loan Repayment Plan in 2025: RAP vs IBR vs Standard

You open your loan servicer email between sips of cold coffee. Another update about court orders, interest, “application reopened,” and you can feel your shoulders tense. You want a plan, but the rules keep shifting, and energy is thin.

Here’s the friction: picking a plan in 2025 feels like aiming at a moving target. SAVE is under legal clouds; IBR is old but steady; and a new plan—RAP—arrives for future borrowers in 2026. Decision fatigue is real.

One nudge for today: a 15‑minute Repayment Check‑In. The goal isn’t to master everything—it’s to make one confident choice for this season and set a tiny reminder for the next milestone.

How to do it in 15 minutes

Open StudentAid’s Loan Simulator and compare monthly payment, total paid, and forgiveness timing across your available plans. Update your income and family size to keep results meaningful. [See the official Loan Simulator overview.] (Source 12)
Decide your default for 2025 (often IBR vs Standard), with RAP noted as a future possibility if you’ll borrow new loans in 2026 or later. (Sources 1, 2, 6, 8–10)
Leave yourself one reminder for the next trigger (see If‑Then plans below) so future‑you can act without an energy spike.

Three variations for different personalities

Quick Decider: Choose the best 2025 plan after one Simulator run; save a screenshot; write a single If‑Then line.
Careful Planner: Compare two scenarios (current income vs expected raise) in the Simulator; pick the plan that holds up best across both; save both screenshots.
PSLF Seeker: Confirm your plan earns qualifying payments; select an IDR option (often IBR) to keep a balance eligible for forgiveness, not the 10‑year Standard that typically leaves little to forgive. (Source 13)

What’s changing—and what’s steady in 2025

SAVE injunction and forbearance interest

If you were placed into SAVE administrative forbearance due to the court injunction, interest began accruing again on August 1, 2025. You may want to review alternatives if eligible and watch for servicer notices as systems adjust. (Sources 4, 5, 10)
The Department of Education reopened revised IDR and consolidation applications on March 26, 2025 after a court‑ordered pause. If your application was held up, you can reapply on StudentAid.gov. (Source 3)

IBR remains the stable IDR anchor

IBR uses a percentage of your discretionary income—10% for “new borrowers” under statutory rules and 15% otherwise—with forgiveness after 20 or 25 years. Payments are also capped so they don’t exceed what you’d pay on the 10‑year Standard amount for your debt. (Sources 6, 7)
In a year of uncertainty for SAVE, many borrowers who need income‑based relief favor IBR for its clear, statute‑backed design and well‑established rules. (Sources 6, 10)

PSLF alignment still matters

PSLF requires 120 qualifying payments under an IDR plan or the 10‑year Standard, but the 10‑year Standard usually leaves no remaining balance to forgive—so most PSLF seekers use an IDR plan. (Source 13)

RAP is coming—but mostly for future borrowers

Congress created the Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP), effective July 1, 2026, with a sliding percentage of Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) and forgiveness after up to 30 years. (Source 1)
For new loans disbursed on or after July 1, 2026, most IDR options sunset; borrowers will generally choose between RAP and a revised Standard plan. (Sources 1, 2, 8)
The revised Standard plan for future borrowers sets term lengths by balance (10, 15, 20, or 25 years). (Source 2)
Early analysis suggests RAP could lower payments for some middle‑income borrowers, but very low or high earners might pay more over a lifetime. Use modeling before opting in when it becomes available. (Source 9)
Note: RAP here refers to the new U.S. federal plan. Canada has a separate, unrelated RAP—don’t mix them up. (Source 14)

AGI vs discretionary income (why it matters)

RAP keys off AGI in a sliding scale. (Source 1)
IBR uses discretionary income as defined in federal regulation—different baseline, different math, different outcomes. (Source 7)
Because the formulas differ, the “cheapest” plan depends on your profile. Run Loan Simulator before switching. (Source 12)

Standard plan basics

Standard typically minimizes total interest paid over time by using fixed payments; monthly amounts are often higher than IDR in early years.
If you plan to pursue PSLF, the 10‑year Standard usually leaves little to forgive; an IDR plan is generally more strategic. (Source 13)
For future borrowers (new loans starting July 1, 2026), Standard terms will follow balance‑based 10/15/20/25‑year lengths, per the proposed changes. (Source 2)

Parent PLUS note

The relevant income‑driven plan in regulation is Income‑Contingent Repayment (ICR). Eligibility details for Parent PLUS are defined in federal rules; confirm specifics in the e‑CFR and via StudentAid.gov’s tools before making changes. (Sources 7, 12)
If this applies to you, include Parent PLUS/ICR in your Simulator run and verify plan‑switch rules in the regulation. (Source 7)
Where information is still evolving, ED will release further guidance as implementation continues into 2026–2028. (Source 8)

System updates and delays to watch

During legal and systems updates linked to SAVE, some forgiveness processing (including certain IBR forgiveness cases) experienced temporary pauses. If you’ve passed a forgiveness milestone, document payments and expect adjustments or refunds when processing resumes. (Source 11)
Always read your servicer messages; injunction‑related processing limits and timelines can change. (Sources 4, 5, 8)

How to choose in 2025: a calm decision tree

Start here if you need lower payments now

You want an IDR plan with stable rules and long‑run eligibility: consider IBR. It uses 10% or 15% of discretionary income with 20/25‑year forgiveness, and it caps payments at the 10‑year Standard amount. (Sources 6, 7)
If you were moved into SAVE administrative forbearance, revisit options; interest accrues as of August 1, 2025. (Sources 4, 5)

Start here if you want the fastest payoff

Standard often minimizes total interest paid if you can afford the monthly amount and aren’t pursuing PSLF. (Source 13)
For new loans you may take in 2026 or later, be aware that Standard terms will vary by balance from 10 to 25 years. (Source 2)

Start here if you’re planning PSLF

Use an IDR plan (often IBR in 2025) to keep qualifying payments flowing and maintain a remaining balance to forgive after 120 payments. Avoid the 10‑year Standard if your goal is PSLF forgiveness. (Source 13)

Start here if you’ll borrow in 2026+

Expect a different menu: generally RAP or the revised Standard plan for those new loans. Model your likely income path to understand how RAP’s AGI‑based design compares to Standard and to legacy IBR on pre‑2026 debt. (Sources 1, 2, 9)

If‑Then micro‑plans (copy these)

If my IDR application was paused in early 2025, then I submit the revised form on StudentAid.gov this week. (Source 3)
If my account shows SAVE administrative forbearance history, then I check interest accrual from August 1, 2025 and run Loan Simulator before changing plans. (Sources 4, 5, 12)
If I’m pursuing PSLF, then I pick an IDR plan (often IBR) rather than 10‑year Standard to keep a balance to forgive. (Source 13)
If I’m likely to take new loans in 2026+, then I note that my future menu will be RAP or revised Standard and set a reminder to re‑model when RAP launches. (Sources 1, 2, 8, 9, 12)
If I have Parent PLUS loans, then I review ICR eligibility and switching rules in the e‑CFR and test scenarios in Loan Simulator before acting. (Sources 7, 12)

Copyable prompts (DM yourself or set as lock‑screen)

“Open Loan Simulator; choose one plan for 2025.”
“IBR vs Standard: Which costs less for my path?”
“PSLF? Pick an IDR, not 10‑year Standard.”
“SAVE forbearance? Check interest; rerun the numbers.”
“2026 loans: RAP or Standard—model both later.”
“Parent PLUS? Check ICR rules before switching.”

A tiny systems boost for future‑you

Make the right action the easy action: rename your budget category to a verb you’ll act on. For example, “Student Loans — Check Simulator.” If you use a simple, privacy‑respecting tracker like Monee, a tiny rename turns an intention into a cue—no slog, no ads, just your next step.

What we don’t know yet (and how to proceed anyway)

Implementation details will continue to roll out as ED updates systems and guidance through 2026–2028. Plan to re‑check official updates when RAP approaches. (Source 8)
Analyses of RAP’s effects are early; outcomes vary by income path. Model a few trajectories in the Simulator so your plan holds up under change. (Sources 1, 9, 12)
Legal and systems shifts may temporarily delay processing (e.g., IBR forgiveness adjustments), so keep your records tight. (Source 11)

Gentle close You don’t need a perfect plan—just a workable one for this season. Take the 15 minutes. Run the Simulator. Pick your now‑plan (IBR vs Standard), leave a single reminder for RAP‑era updates, and let the system carry you when motivation dips.

How to Choose a Student Loan Repayment Plan in 2025: RAP vs IBR vs Standard

Sources:

Discover Monee - Budget & Expense Tracker