How to Compare Flights by the Real Price (Fare + Bags + Seats + Fees) with a 4‑Number Checklist

If you’ve ever thought “How did this €129 flight turn into €214?”—you’re not imagining it. Airlines increasingly “unbundle” the trip: the base fare is just the entry ticket, and the real flight price is the bundle you actually end up buying.

That’s not a fringe issue. Industry-wide, ancillary services (the add-ons) are projected to reach $145B in 2025—14.4% of total revenue—which tells you how central fees are to the pricing model. (IATA press release)

And in the U.S., these add-ons are big enough to show up as major revenue lines: $5.7B in baggage fees and $902M in reservation change fees in 2023 domestic operating revenue. (BTS release)

Seat fees, too, can be substantial and variable. A U.S. Senate investigation summary highlights dynamic/algorithmic pricing for fees—especially seats—and cites $12.4B in seat-fee revenue (2018–2023) across five airlines. (Senate PSI press release) Reuters also reports the panel’s criticism and repeats that $12.4B figure. (Reuters seat-fee story)

So yes—comparing flights by base fare alone is structurally misleading. Here’s the simple fix: a 4-number checklist that forces every option onto the same “real price” footing.

The 4‑Number Checklist (Copy‑Paste)

Use this as your “receipt math” before you pick a flight:

Fare (what you pay to board)
Bags (carry-on + checked + how you’ll pay)
Seats (what you actually need, not what’s marketed)
Fees / Flex (change/cancel terms + booking channel protections)

Copy‑paste worksheet

Fill one block per flight option:

Option name: Airline + flight times + booking channel (airline vs OTA)
Assumptions: City: Munich · Travelers: 2 adults + 1 child · Search date: 2025--
1) Fare: €____ per person × ____ = €____
2) Bags:
- Carry-on: €____ × ____ = €____
- Checked: €____ × ____ = €____
- Payment timing: (online prepay / airport)
- Bags total: €____
3) Seats: €____ per seat × ____ seats = €____
4) Fees/Flex: change/cancel cost or restrictions = €____ (or note)
Real price total: €____

Number 1: Fare (Don’t Stop at the Headline Price)

Regulators even use “true cost” language: the U.S. DOT frames the true cost as the fare plus “critical extra service fees” (like bags/carry-on and change/cancel) and pushed for those fees to be disclosed upfront at the first point fare and schedule info is shown (not hidden behind a hyperlink). (U.S. DOT press release)

Reality check: a U.S. appeals court temporarily blocked that disclosure rule, which means you should assume fee visibility can still be inconsistent—especially on metasearch sites and some online travel agencies (OTAs). (Reuters court story)

What to do (practical): treat the fare as “number one,” but don’t emotionally commit to it until you’ve written down numbers 2–4.

Number 2: Bags (Carry‑On + Checked + How You’ll Pay)

Bags are one of the most common “leaky costs,” and they’re explicitly part of what DOT calls “critical extra service fees.” (U.S. DOT press release)

A consumer-facing snapshot notes two especially important realities:

Paying timing matters: prepaying bags online can avoid higher airport charges.
Fare tier matters: basic-economy restrictions can change what’s allowed, including carry-on allowances. (Condé Nast Traveler)

Bags mini-checklist (copy‑paste):

Carry-on included? If not, price it.
Checked bag needed? Price it for your payment method (online vs airport).
Is this basic economy? If yes, double-check baggage/carry-on restrictions.

Number 3: Seats (Often Optional, Often Dynamic)

Here’s a booking-screen trap: making it feel like you must pay for a seat to proceed.

The DOT has been explicit that consumers must be told a seat is included and they’re not required to pay for a seat assignment. (U.S. DOT press release)

At the same time, seat fees can be large and change quickly. The Senate PSI summary and Reuters reporting both highlight dynamic/algorithmic pricing for fees and the scale of seat-fee revenue. (Senate PSI press release, Reuters seat-fee story)

Seats decision rule (calm and guilt-free):

If you don’t care where you sit, set Seats = €0 and move on.
If you need something specific (sitting together, extra space, aisle for a nervous flyer), capture the actual seat price shown for your exact flight/date—don’t assume a “typical” number. (Senate PSI press release)

Number 4: Fees / Flex (The Hidden Value of “I Can Fix This”)

Flexibility is part of the real price: change and cancellation terms (and the “risk-free” window) can be worth real money when plans are fragile.

A key policy detail many shoppers miss: for tickets bought 7+ days before departure, airlines must offer either a 24‑hour full refund option or a 24‑hour hold at the quoted price—but the DOT notes this 24-hour requirement does not apply to tickets purchased via online travel agencies/travel agents. (U.S. DOT refunds page)

Translation into your checklist: booking channel can change your “real price,” because protections can change. If you want that 24-hour safety net, “book direct” (or “confirm the OTA policy in writing”) belongs in the math.

A Real-Price Comparison Example (With Clear Assumptions)

Assumptions for this example (illustrative only; fees vary by airline/route/fare tier):
City: Munich · Travelers: 2 adults + 1 child · Search date: 2025-- · One carry-on + one checked bag total · Seats together desired.

Option	Fare	Bags	Seats	Fees/Flex	Real Price
A (looks cheaper)	€120 × 3 = €360	€60	€75	€0	€495
B (looks pricier)	€145 × 3 = €435	€30	€0	€0	€465

Bullet math (why B wins):

Option A beats B on fare by €75
But A adds €105 more in bags + seats
Net: €30 cheaper to take B once you price the bundle you’ll actually buy

If this kind of “quiet €30–€90 swing” happens twice in a year, that’s a meaningful household win—without sacrificing what your family needs.

Step-by-Step: How to Capture the 4 Numbers (Like a Screenshot Walkthrough)

Pick one flight you’re considering (times + airline). Write the base fare as “Fare.”
Open the baggage details and write Bags as two lines: carry-on and checked—plus whether the price changes if you prepay online. (Condé Nast Traveler)
Click through to seats and decide what you actually need. Remember: you’re not required to pay for a seat assignment. (U.S. DOT press release)
Check change/cancel terms and write your Fees/Flex note. If you want the 24-hour safety net, verify you’re eligible—especially if you’re not booking direct. (U.S. DOT refunds page)
Before deciding, verify the total on the airline checkout page. Fee disclosure can vary across channels, and the DOT’s upfront disclosure rule has faced legal blockage. (Reuters court story)

Polite Scripts You Can Use (Copy‑Paste)

1) To an OTA (confirming the 24-hour policy)

“Hi! Before I book, can you confirm in writing whether this ticket qualifies for a 24-hour full refund option or a 24-hour hold at the quoted price? If not, what is your exact cancellation/refund policy within 24 hours?”

(Why: the DOT notes the 24-hour requirement may not apply to tickets purchased via online travel agencies/travel agents.) (U.S. DOT refunds page)

2) To an airline/agent (confirming what’s optional vs required)

“Hi! I’m comparing options by the total cost. Can you confirm whether a seat is included with this fare and that I’m not required to pay for a seat assignment? Also, can you point me to the bag and change/cancel fees for this itinerary?”

(Why: DOT guidance emphasizes that consumers must be told a seat is included and not required to pay for a seat assignment.) (U.S. DOT press release)

The Calm Bottom Line

A “cheap flight” is only cheap if it’s cheap for your family’s bundle: the bags you’ll bring, the seats you’ll accept, and the flexibility you need.

Write down the 4 numbers, verify totals at checkout (especially across booking channels), and let the math make the decision—no guilt, no guessing, no surprise add-ons.

How to Compare Flights by the Real Price (Fare + Bags + Seats + Fees) with a 4‑Number Checklist

How to Compare Flights by the Real Price (Fare + Bags + Seats + Fees) with a 4‑Number Checklist

The 4‑Number Checklist (Copy‑Paste)

Copy‑paste worksheet

Number 1: Fare (Don’t Stop at the Headline Price)

Number 2: Bags (Carry‑On + Checked + How You’ll Pay)

Number 3: Seats (Often Optional, Often Dynamic)

Number 4: Fees / Flex (The Hidden Value of “I Can Fix This”)

A Real-Price Comparison Example (With Clear Assumptions)

Step-by-Step: How to Capture the 4 Numbers (Like a Screenshot Walkthrough)

Polite Scripts You Can Use (Copy‑Paste)

1) To an OTA (confirming the 24-hour policy)

2) To an airline/agent (confirming what’s optional vs required)

The Calm Bottom Line

Sources:

Discover Monee - Budget & Expense Tracker